QB Stock Market: One Burning Question for Every 2026 Starter

It’s rare, at this point in the offseason, to have such a good sense of who will be starting where. But there aren’t many openings at quarterback around the NFL. Given that only the Las Vegas Raiders are certain to draft a QB in the first round, other teams have scrambled to put their guys into place via free agency. So, obviously, let’s rank the starters. What else are we going to do with our free time in the offseason? But let’s acknowledge that — while the identity of nearly every team’s QB1 is fairly clear — there is plenty of uncertainty around each starter’s situation. So, along with the ranking, I’m here to offer one burning question for every QB. Previous: 2025 final rankings 2025 final rank: N/A If Aaron Rodgers isn’t coming back, what the heck are the Steelers going to do at QB? 2025 final rank: 27 With the Browns obviously thinking about the QBs in the 2027 NFL Draft, can Shedeur prove he’s QB1 material despite this bad situation? 2025 final rank: N/A Was all that 2025 production a sign of competence — or just a result of garbage time? 2025 final rank: 30 With a competent offensive-minded head coach and an impressive supporting cast, could Tua actually be good again? 2025 final rank: 24 Is he the guy — and then some — who showed up in the second half of the year? 2025 final rank: 29 Same city. Different Geno? 2025 final rank: 21 Just how long will it take him to get fully back from his injuries (Achilles, broken fibula)? 2025 final rank: N/A Everyone keeps saying the presumptive No. 1 pick is pro-ready, so how long can the Raiders keep him on the bench? 2025 final rank: 22 Can Young close the gap between an upward-trending QB (what he is now) to a franchise QB (what he needs to be to earn an extension and have a future in Carolina)? 2025 final rank: N/A Is Willis the second coming of Matt Flynn or Jalen Hurts? 2025 final rank: 23 Is new Titans OC Brian Daboll about to do with Ward what he did with Josh Allen? 2025 final rank: 25 Can new Giants HC John Harbaugh get Dart to stop taking massive hits? 2025 final rank: 16 What the heck has happened to Stroud since his rookie season? 2025 final rank: 26 Will Murray unlock something new for HC Kevin O’Connell’s offense — or cause pure chaos? 2025 final rank: 9 Is he HC Sean Payton’s puppet in the pocket — or can Nix evolve into a game-changer? 2025 final rank: 20 Was Mayfield’s success a product of a strong supporting cast or will a declining group continue to drag him down? 2025 final rank: 11 Has he grown out of the meltdown games? 2025 final rank: 18 Is Hurts an at-any-cost winner or is he really just struggling to be a system quarterback? 2025 final rank: 19 Will he stay healthy enough to dominate in the ways he did during the second half of his rookie season? 2025 final rank: 10 Can Williams improve his career 60.3% completion rate to league average (64.3% in 2025) in HC Ben Johnson’s offense? 2025 final rank: 8 Is this the season when Lawrence establishes himself among the unquestioned elite? 2025 final rank: 7 Is new offensive coordinator Drew Petzing, who had Jacoby Brissett averaging 240 passing yards per game in Arizona, as underrated as I think he is? 2025 final rank: 15 What led to Jackson’s major statistical regression last year: injuries, coaching tensions or a more serious athletic decline? 2025 final rank: 5 Can he recreate his 2025 season — but this time while supported by a legitimate defense? 2025 final rank: 6 Was Purdy’s creativity and playmaking a sign that his ceiling is higher than generally believed? 2025 final rank: 12 Can new OC Mike McDaniel make sure the offense doesn’t completely implode around Herbert this year? 2025 final rank: 13 Can Mahomes get back on top despite his ACL injury — and on the heels of the worst season of his career? 2025 final rank: 1 How much can guard Alijah Vera-Tucker and slot receiver Romeo Doubs help Maye fight off what feels like inevitable regression? 2025 final rank: 4 Even knowing that his advanced statistics are among the league’s best, can he level up to the top tier of QBs? 2025 final rank: 14 Will this be a make-or-break year for Bengals coach Zac Taylor? 2025 final rank: 2 Can he play like the MVP again? 2025 final rank: 3 Are the Bills building a team that can, at least, stop holding Allen back?